Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in Peoria
Best Italian Restaurants in Peoria

Best Italian Restaurants in Peoria

Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars

Home › Where to Eat › Best Italian Restaurants in Peoria

Peoria's Italian dining scene is a delightful surprise that rivals much larger cities, offering everything from authentic family recipes passed down through generations to innovative twists on classic dishes. What sets this heartland destination apart is its perfect blend of old-school trattorias where the sauce simmers all day and modern Italian kitchens pushing creative boundaries. Whether you're craving hand-tossed pizza with perfectly charred crusts, silky house-made pasta, or contemporary Italian fare that would make nonna proud, Peoria's Italian restaurants deliver with remarkable consistency and passion.

This carefully curated guide showcases 10 exceptional Italian establishments, each boasting ratings of 4.5 stars or higher from thousands of satisfied diners. You'll discover intimate neighborhood gems where the owner greets you like family, lively spots perfect for date nights with extensive wine lists, and casual pizzerias that have perfected their craft over decades. From traditional Sicilian preparations to fire-kissed specialties and everything in between, these restaurants represent the very best of Peoria's Italian culinary landscape, proving that outstanding Italian cuisine thrives far beyond the coasts.

Featured Restaurants

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant
$$

Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆
4.7
(9,007 reviews)

This beloved Italian chain delivers an authentic family-style dining experience with generous portions served in a warm, bustling atmosphere that keeps locals and visitors coming back, as evidenced by nearly 9,000 glowing reviews. Travelers rave about the consistent quality and lively environment that makes every meal feel like a celebration with friends. Come hungry and ready to share - the massive portions are designed for groups, making it perfect for families or anyone looking to feast Italian-style.

16091 N Arrowhead Fountains Center Dr, Peoria, AZ 85382, USA
The Sicilian Butcher
$$

The Sicilian Butcher

★★★★☆
4.7
(5,273 reviews)

This beloved Sicilian-style bakery and specialty store has won over thousands of locals and visitors with its authentic Italian offerings and welcoming atmosphere, earning an impressive 4.7-star rating from over 5,000 reviews. The combination of fresh-baked goods and imported Italian products creates a true taste of Sicily that keeps customers coming back for more. Arrive early in the day for the best selection of fresh pastries and breads, as the most popular items tend to sell out quickly.

9780 W Northern Ave Suite 1100, Peoria, AZ 85345, USA
Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana
$$

Fabio On Fire | Pizzeria Italiana

★★★★☆
4.5
(1,260 reviews)

Fabio On Fire delivers authentic Italian pizzeria charm in Peoria, drawing food lovers with their passionate approach to traditional Italian cooking and warm, welcoming atmosphere. With an impressive 4.5-star rating from over 1,200 reviews, travelers consistently rave about the quality ingredients, generous portions, and friendly service that make every meal memorable. Arrive early during weekend dinner hours to snag the best seats, and don't hesitate to ask your server about daily specials that showcase seasonal ingredients.

8275 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy #101, Peoria, AZ 85382, USA
Twisted Italian
$$

Twisted Italian

★★★★☆
4.6
(1,097 reviews)

Twisted Italian in Peoria delivers exceptional dining with its creative take on Italian cuisine, earning an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 1,000 satisfied diners who consistently praise both the food quality and welcoming atmosphere. The restaurant's high rating suggests reliable execution of classic dishes with modern twists, making it a dependable choice for both casual dinners and special occasions. For the best experience, consider making reservations during peak dinner hours, as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly with both locals and visitors.

9940 W Happy Valley Pkwy #1080, Peoria, AZ 85383, USA
Connected
$$$

Connected

★★★★☆
4.7
(1,065 reviews)

Connected draws locals and visitors alike with its welcoming bar atmosphere and consistently excellent service, earning an impressive 4.7-star rating from over 1,000 reviewers. The upscale pricing reflects quality ingredients and skilled preparation, making it a reliable choice for both casual drinks and elevated bar fare. Visit during off-peak hours to fully enjoy the ambiance, as this popular Peoria hotspot tends to fill up quickly on weekends.

3218 N Dries Ln, Peoria, IL 61604, USA
Peoria LaGondola Spaghetti House + Leonardo's
$

Peoria LaGondola Spaghetti House + Leonardo's

★★★★☆
4.5
(624 reviews)

This beloved Peoria institution combines classic Italian comfort food with a welcoming family atmosphere that has earned rave reviews from over 600 diners. The generous portions and consistent quality keep both locals and visitors coming back, making it a reliable choice for satisfying pasta dishes without breaking the bank. Arrive early during peak dinner hours as this popular spot can get busy, especially on weekends when families flock here for their Italian favorites.

700 E War Memorial Dr, Peoria, IL 61614, USA
Rizzi's Italian Restaurant
$$

Rizzi's Italian Restaurant

★★★★☆
4.5
(613 reviews)

Rizzi's Italian Restaurant has earned a stellar reputation among locals and visitors alike, with over 600 glowing reviews praising its authentic Italian atmosphere and consistently delicious fare. The restaurant's impressive 4.5-star rating speaks to its ability to deliver both quality food and warm, welcoming service that keeps diners coming back. For the best experience, consider making reservations during peak dinner hours, as this popular Peoria gem tends to fill up quickly with both families and couples seeking a memorable Italian meal.

4613 N Sheridan Rd, Peoria, IL 61614, USA

Culinary Experiences in Peoria

Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences